12th Class English Indigo - Louis Fischer

  • question_answer 13)
    Discuss the following: ‘Freedom from fear is more important than legal justice for the poor.’ Do you think that the poor of India are free from fear after Independence?    

    Answer:

    As the rich and well-heeled made preparations to ring in 2007 in style across a new, shining India, a wave of revulsion swept through the country after the report of mass killings in a sleepy, poor housing area. This was in Nithari, no more than eighteen miles from the capital, Delhi, and in one of India's most prosperous and upcoming districts, Noida. Violent death involving such larger numbers is not so rare in India, neither is police inefficiency, especially where the poor are concerned. Then, why did Nithari provoke a diferent response? Because this case illustrates best, the most barbaric and basic truth about the Indian state.   That it has Jailed the country's poor.   It is one example of how the poor and weak have Just no place in the Indian system It is also deeply concerning how the Indian media has been sucked into covering the relatively more mundane, but sensational issues. The media had heard of reports of children disappearing but no one took the trouble to take up the issue. The Indian system has become completely insensitive and mdiferent to the poor. The ineficiency of the police is Just a cover-up as this could never have happened if the victims belonged to a rich or middle-class neighborhood.   Speaking to a BBC Hindi service show, one of India's most celebrated police oficers, Kiran Bedi said that the Nithari case was an example of how, for the common man in the country there is no police or Justice system. The system needs to be completely overhauled and wide-ranging reforms are needed in the police structure,' she said.   She is right. But only police reforms will not do. The entire system and attitudes desperately need to be reformed.                                                                    India's economic prowess and potential is much talked about but can we say with the same degree of optimism that there will not be another Nithari, when India does realize its dreams?   


You need to login to perform this action.
You will be redirected in 3 sec spinner